Opposition MPs urge immediate move to level 1

National MP Amy Adams. Photo: RNZ / Dom Thomas

Senior opposition MPs are clamouring for New Zealand to move to alert level 1 immediately, but leader Todd Muller is taking a more cautious stance.

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern revealed this morning that Cabinet would look at relaxing restrictions as early as next week.

Next week's decision comes sooner than had been originally signalled by Jacinda Ardern, but not soon enough for some of National's front bench.

Amy Adams, National's number-three ranked MP who holds the party's Covid-19 Recovery portfolio, backed an immediate move.

"There is very strong evidence New Zealand should be in level 1 now ... given we are in level 2 the government has to be very clear about how those rules are enforced."

Former deputy leader and frontbencher Paula Bennett says the events of the long weekend, including Black Lives Matter protests in major cities, further showed why New Zealand should be moved out of level 2 immediately.

"We should be at level 1 or zero ... people should be able to protest if they want to, we need consistent rules that are fair for all and it's totally ridiculous that we're still having such restrictions when people are not abiding by them."

Those stated positions went further than their leader Todd Muller was willing to go - he would only say the shift should come as soon as possible.

"I'm not the Prime Minister, I don't get to see the advice which balances those competing objectives," Muller said.

Ardern says New Zealand was doing better than expected in its battle with Covid-19 and so an earlier move to level 1 is possible. Until then, she said, the rules remained and people must follow them.

"They're there for now for a reason, we've succeeded so far, if we want to continue to be successful we just have to hang in there."

That puts Ardern at odds with her coalition partner, Winston Peters, who - like National - wants level 1 now. 

At her weekly post-Cabinet media briefing, she says Peters had expressed that view to her privately before going public with it.

"He had a view that we should move as of Monday ... obviously my job is to balance all of the advice that we receive from the scientists.

"We had a consensus decision, although there was an alternate view presented by some members at the Cabinet table.

"It will not surprise people... to know that from time to time the deputy PM and I will take a different view, and colleagues around the Cabinet table will take a different view."

Muller says Ardern and Peters must get on the same page as they were confusing the public.

Ardern says she would provide more information to the public this week on what level 1 would look like.


More on SunLive...
1 Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment. Login Now


Posted on 02-06-2020 19:54 | By Merlin

Amy Adams says there is evidence we should be in level one now.Todd Muller says he doe not get to see the advice given to the government. Perhaps he should ask Amy Adams for the information as she says there is evidence.Confusing.